The post I said I’d do, but never did…
So, a while back after we returned from New York City, I mentioned that we saw Dr. Micheal Ain. Dr. Ain is an Orthopedic Surgeon from John Hopkins Medical Center. I had spoken with him previously while we were in Detroit for LPA’s National conference in 2008. Dr. Ain is well respected within the dwarfism community, not only because of his patients with Achondroplasia, but also because he has Achondroplasia.
When I saw Dr. Ain during one of the medical seminars, I asked his opinion regarding children with Achondroplasia and progressive Kyphosis. Now, this question was not asking about Kyphosis in general, but progressive Kyphosis in children, specifically under 2. At the time I explained that Knoah has been in bracing therapy since he was 7 months old. When we started it, his Kyphotic curve was hovering around 30+ degrees, which is nearly unheard of in a child under the age of 7, but it does happen.
January 05, 2007

May 23, 2007

January 21, 2008

A year later, Knoah’s curve was at 65+ degrees even during bracing. So, Dr. Ain suggested I make an impromptu appointment so we could see him and he could examine Knoah. Now, before I set foot into the room, I knew what he was going to say. So, it came as no surprise when he said Knoah needed surgery. It also came as no surprise when he said Knoah needs surgery NOW. Although hearing it and thinking it are two separate things.
Now comes the “debate”. We all know by now ALL children with Achondroplasia have Kyphosis. We also know that in 90% of cases the Kyphosis resolves on it’s own as the child starts walking. The 10% that don’t resolve will go into bracing therapy around age 4 and continue until age 7 or 8. By this point the Kyphosis should be resolved or minimized under 10 degrees or so. Out of that 10%, maybe 4% will end up needing spinal surgery or a spinal fusion by the time their 15.
Our problem. Knoah just turned 3. He is 1 out of say 2 children (39,998 have Achondroplasia) with such a progressive Kyphosis that bracing is not working.
There is no reference guide, no text books nor medical journals that chronicle a 3 year having a spinal fusion or Laminectomy. With a progressive Kyphosis, damage can occur to the vertebrae. This is called Anterior Wedging. When the vertebrae start to hit each other, bone fragments start to break off. This leads to symptoms such as back pain, respiratory dysfunction, neurologic involvement, or symptoms of spinal stenosis.
So, we are left asking, what do we do? Will and differ on opinions. He suggests we contact Ain and have the surgery done. I say get a third opinion before we throw Knoah on the table. So, where do we go? We already see Dr. Pauli and he says NO SURGERY! That’s one opinion. We saw Dr. Ain and he says SURGERY NOW! There’s two. We need a third opinion.
I understand Dr. Pauli’s reasoning. Surgery at this point is way too aggressive, especially given Knoah’s age. We would be looking at nearly 8 weeks at John Hopkins for the surgery and recovery. Another 12 weeks of sustained recovery and therapy and we are not talking the any complications that may arise or the issue with transportation, travel expenses, lodging, etc. The cost of such a thing would be insurmountable. However, if it HAS to be done, we will do it.
So, I guess, I am looking for your advice. Who do you see for an Orthopedic Surgeon? Has your child had a spinal fusion and what was it like. Who would you recommend for us to see to get a third opinion.
I have been sitting on this for 4 months because while Knoah is not showing signs of pain or neurological issues, we don’t want to wait either.




This post has 13 comments
November 19th, 2009
We are also waiting for a 3rd opinion for our daughter Kayla for surgery. We have received opinions from Weiner and Ain so far. I have sent off x-rays to MacKenzie in Philadelphia. I’m hoping to get an answer before Thanksgiving, 60% of his patients are LP’s. I know 2 families here in Columbus, Ohio who have gone through what you are going through. They went to different Doctors when there sons were young and now only see Ain and Carson. They won’t let any other ortho docs do surgery on their son. If you would like I can put you in touch with them. If you decide to go to John Hopkins they have a childrens house that you can all stay at that is very reasonable and it’s right across the street from the hospital. I think that you should get opinions until you feel comfortable with that Doctor and the procedure. I know it’s not easy, but you will make the right decision. You can contact me at chetrick@columbus.rr.com
November 19th, 2009
I know 2 families here in columbus, ohio who have gone through what you are. They both have boys and they are now 11 and 12. They will only work with Dr. Ain and Carson. There is a childrens home across the street from John Hopkins that you can stay at. If you want to talk with them email and I will put you in touch with them. We are waiting for a 3rd opinion from Dr. MacKenzie in Philadelphia. Good Luck!! chetrick@columbus.rr.com
November 19th, 2009
I suggest Dr. William Puffenbarger in OKC at OU Children’s Medical Center. He gives you a straight answer and he doesn’t resolve to surgery. He doesn’t want to go straight to surgery. My daughter was at over 80 degree and after a year it had improved. I suggest letting Knoah set the course. Dr. Puff said not to push my daughter. Watch how she sits, if she appears tired then let her lay down and rest. She will turn four next month and I still encourage her to rest when need be. She is also a 3rd generation dwarf. I had a lamenectomy at 5. I don’t want the same thing for her or her sister.
November 20th, 2009
I got no advice for you. I’m just sitting here with tears in my eyes thinking about all of this — and if just reading about someone else’s child facing this makes me tear up, I can’t imagine how you’re feeling.
What a tough choice you’ve been presented with! It stinks. I know that you just want to do what’s best for your wonderful kid. And when you’re not sure which path is the right one to take because there is no absolutely right answer — well, that has to be beyond awful.
I’ve never been in a situation like this one for myself or my loved ones. But one small question comes to mind for Dr Pauli. (It’s probably not even a good question, I don’t know enough to ask those.) How bad would Knoah’s kyphosis need to be for Dr Pauli to recommend surgery sooner rather than later? I’m sure he has a treatment plan in mind which includes that possibility.
I’ll be sending good thoughts and wishes your way. I wish I had more to offer than that.
November 20th, 2009
hi my son ethan has achondroplasia he is 2 and has been in a brace now for 4 months, 18 months ago he measured 43 degrees and now he’s measuring 63 degrees, the doctor hasn’t a lot of experience with little people as we live in england, he has said that ethan will have to wear the brace for another year to see if that helps. hopefully now ethans walking that will help straighten him up.
November 20th, 2009
It never hurts to get another opinion. Is there another doctor in the area you trust?
November 20th, 2009
Tonya, I am so sorry you are faced with this decision. I can’t imagine the stress that is weighing on your mind. I think you are right to seek a third opinion. We see Dr. Mackenzie at DuPont in Wilmington, DE. He is wonderful and I trust him implicitly. I know many families have sent x-rays for him to evaluate without having to travel there for a visit. Similar to Hopkins, there is a wonderful Ronald McDonald House right across from DuPont, should you need to stay there. Here is the website: http://nemours.org/hospital/de/aidhc/service/skeletal.html
Best of luck! Keep us posted!
November 20th, 2009
Boy, that’s a TOUGH one. Ain and Pauli are supposed to be the best and they COMPLETELY disagree on this. AHHHHH!Sounds like you’ve got some good ideas for a 3rd opinion and I hope one of them works. Keeping my fingers crossed!
Lisa
November 20th, 2009
Oh boy! Wow! Looking at those pictures of Knoah’s back I was surprised! From the other pictures I have seen of him his clothing must hide the severity of this! We see Dr. Ain and he is currently concerned for Sonya’s C1C2 spine instability and see’s a future fusion down the road. We also see Dr. Leet (ortho) at Kennedy Krieger Institute near Hopkins who agrees. However our docs at AI duPont in DE don’t see this. We see Dr. Kruse (OI ortho) at duPont and Dr. Bober (genetics) but I’m sure that Dr. Mackenzie would be a good choice as he is well respected in the dwarfism community as well! I do know of one family in Columbus OH whose child with Campomelic Dysplasia has had many spinal fusions with Dr. Ain for his severe kyphosis and scoliosis. I think he had his first fusion at a young age, but not as young as Knoah. I have heard that dr. Ain likes to operate, that is coming from Dr. Bober… not sure on it’s truth. How frustrating! We are thinking of you all and saying prayers! Hugs!
November 22nd, 2009
I’m so sorry that you are faced with this tough decision, but I too would look for a third opinion. Simon sees Dr. Ain, and he is wonderful and we trust him, but that is tough when you have two top doctors disagreeing on this. I wish I had more advice for you. We are thinking of you guys and praying that you get the answers you need soon!
November 23rd, 2009
You know that you and I talked about this the other night and we will talk more about it tonight. I just hope you can get a third opinion that you feel comfortable with. You know I am a bit partial to you being in Baltimore for selfish reasons of being able to visit you. LOL (like when you told Will you could move to Richmond because I was here). You know that you have to do what is best for our little Knoah.
P.S. there is a package on it’s way for Knoah.
November 23rd, 2009
I know a woman who took her daughter to see Dr. Ain several years ago. He recommended surgery for her daughter’s kyphosis. They were pretty shocked to here that, so they got another opinion. They went to California to see an orthopedic doctor. I think she said his name was Toller, or something like that. I am pretty sure at that time he was practicing at the Cedars-Sinai Clinic. The second opinion did not recommend surgery. I could find out more specifics if you want me to do that.
January 2nd, 2010
Wow, is all I can say. I know that the kyphosis of the spine has to be watched but never knew how bad it could get. Nate saw an orthopeadiac surgeron at 19 months and was cleared. We also saw Dr. Mckenzie at an medical convention in Indianapolis and was told everything was good. I really like him and would continue to see/consult with him. I think there is another doc with a rally long name. I’ll search for the info if you need it. Other than that I think you need to do what works for your family, helps Knoah the best and has the best outcome/results. I know it’s a lot but an awesome mom like you can do it!